Phidias

GI
1.7
Overall Score
VS
Winner

Take Profit Trader

US
7.9
Overall Score
The Verdict

Take Profit Trader is an established US-based firm founded in 2021 with 5 years of operating history. It offers a comprehensive platform selection and has earned solid AI evaluation scores across most categories, particularly in technology (10/10) and rules clarity (8/10). The firm provides daily payouts via Wire or ACH and allows up to 5 funded accounts. At $90 with a 40% discount available, it represents a mid-range entry cost. However, it has no trader reviews on record.

Phidias is a newer Gibraltar-based firm established in 2023 with 3 years of operation. It offers a more competitive entry price at $55 with an 80% discount, and permits significantly more funded accounts (15 versus 5). However, it received notably lower AI evaluation scores across all categories, with particular concerns in support (1/10) and rules transparency (1/10). Payouts are processed through Rise and take 2-5 business days rather than daily. Like Take Profit Trader, Phidias has no trader reviews available.

Both firms support the same core platforms (QuantTower, NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, ATAS, and Sierra Charts) and offer futures trading with identical data feeds. The choice depends on whether you prioritize operational maturity and transparency (Take Profit Trader) or lower costs and account flexibility (Phidias), while being aware of the substantial differences in AI-assessed support quality and rule clarity between them.

Best for - Phidias
Phidias suits cost-conscious traders who want to manage multiple funded accounts and can tolerate longer payout timelines and less transparent support infrastructure.
Best for - Take Profit Trader
Take Profit Trader suits traders who value established operations, transparent rules, daily payouts, and superior technology support.
Year Established
2023
3 years in operation
Year Established
2021
5 years in operation
Head-to-Head Scores
1.7
Overall AI Score
7.9
5.0
Trader Rating
8.3
2
Payouts
8
1
Customer Support
6
1
Rules & Fairness
8
3
Technology
10
20 Reviews Analyzed 20
Trader Score Trend
Key Facts
PhidiasMetricTake Profit Trader
15 Max Funded Accounts 5
Futures Assets Futures
2-5 Days Payout Frequency Daily
Daily Payout Timing Daily
Platforms & Methods
QuantTower QuantTower NinjaTrader NinjaTrader Tradovate Tradovate TradingView TradingView ATAS ATAS Sierra Charts Sierra Charts MotiveWave MotiveWave
Platforms
QuantTower QuantTower NinjaTrader NinjaTrader Tradovate Tradovate TradingView TradingView ATAS ATAS Sierra Charts Sierra Charts WealthCharts WealthCharts MotiveWave MotiveWave
Rithmic Rithmic Tradovate Tradovate
Data Feeds
Rithmic Rithmic Tradovate Tradovate
Rise Rise
Payout Methods
Wire Wire ACH ACH
Pricing & Discounts
From
$55
80% off HONORTRADE26
Visit Phidias
From
$90
40% off NOFEE40
Visit Take Profit Trader